Skip to content

Columbus 1 - 1 NYCFC: Rate the Players

Did NYCFC earn a point on the road against a tough opponent? Or let a win slip through their fingers?

Nicely done | NYCFC.com

New York City FC were moments eight minutes away from pulling off an upset win against Columbus Crew in steamy Ohio, but it wasn’t to be: A Crew reduced to 10 players scored in stoppage time to steal a point at home and crush the souls of NYCFC fans everywhere. It’s a draw that feels like a loss: Here’s your chance to decide the NYCFC player ratings.

The ratings form will remain open until midnight tomorrow, July 9; results will be published on Monday, July 10.

Three thoughts:
• Justin Haak’s goal was a thing of beauty
• The NYCFC midfield created chances but the attack just could finish them (sound familiar?)
• Game management is an issue

Neymar to NYCFC?

Having trouble with the Google Form embedded below? Here’s a direct link to the ballot.

Comments

Latest

2025 Final Grade: David Lee

2025 Final Grade: David Lee

David Lee did some of the best business in his NYCFC career just before leaving, bringing in Nico Fernández Mercau and Aiden O'Neill, and signing Matt Freese to an extension. But he let Justin Haak slip away, and Jovan Mijatović and Talles Magno are still on the club's books.

Members Public