Skip to content

NYCFC vs FC Cincinnati Player Ratings

Another slack performance, another round of poor NYCFC player ratings.

The Iceman played well in his NYCFC debut | Courtesy NYCFC.com

New York City FC player ratings are determined by Hudson River Blue readers — here are your NYCFC player ratings from a New York City loss to FC Cincinnati in the US Open Cup that felt inevitable.


Starting XI

Gabriel Segal (off 61′) – 4.7

The stand-in striker looked more comfortable on the field than in past games, but that doesn’t hide the fact that he had zero shots the entire game. He was awarded a modest 6.2 by FotMob.

Talles Magno (off 61′) – 4.8

Is Talles Magno one of the best young players in MLS? Or a Young Designated Player two years into his contract who has yet to make an impact on this team? Maybe both. FotMob gave him a 6.6.

This post is for subscribers only

Subscribe

Already have an account? Sign In

Latest

2025 Report Card: Alonso Martínez

2025 Report Card: Alonso Martínez

El Clínico finished the season strong, cementing his place as one of the greatest goal-scorers in New York City FC history before sitting out the final playoff games with an ACL injury suffered while on international duty with Costa Rica.

Members Public
2025 Final Grade: Agustín Ojeda

2025 Final Grade: Agustín Ojeda

The 21-year-old winger had a stretch of summer productivity as an assist-maker, but Ojeda's attacking output was missing for much of the season despite his playing in all 43 of New York City FC's 2025 matches.

Members Public