Matt Freese earned the highest score in the history of these reader-generated player ratings for his performance in Game 3 in Cincinnati, and the entire New York City FC backline got high marks for a first clean sheet kept since July.
Playoff wins make for positive player ratings, as four NYCFC players were rated above 8.0 and head coach Nick Cushing got one of his best grades this season.
The MLS Cup Playoffs began for New York City FC with a limp scoreless loss in Cincinnati, and your ratings were not too kind to the team's attacking players.
Participation in this week's ratings is 75% lower than the season average after NYCFC's first-ever loss to Montréal at Stade Saputo. Your indifference is noted.
Santiago Rodríguez added two goals against Nashville SC and is your POTM — his 22 goal involvements this season account for 40.7% of the goals scored by New York City FC.
Santiago Rodríguez is your POTM after becoming the 14th player in NYCFC history to score 10 goals or more in a single season.
The strongest ratings of the year after the biggest win of the season? Yeah, that tracks.
You gave the New York City FC players strong ratings all around for their impressive performance against league-leading Inter Miami, and James Sands is your POTM for his goal — and how he disrupted Lionel Messi.
The four-goal loss to the Union was among the worst home defeats in New York City FC history and you handed out some extremely low player ratings to mark the occasion.
A third straight match that New York City FC failed to win after taking a lead meant low ratings, but Matt Freese's return to health and continued excellence in goal earned him high marks.
El Clínico is your POTM for the third game in a row, and Tayvon Gray has the second-most assists for a defender in NYCFC history. That 2.9 our readers give Luis Barraza? It's the second-lowest player rating handed out this year.
El Clínico is your POTM for the second consecutive match, after NYCFC stumbled for the second consecutive match.
It ended in disappointment in Columbus, but a record-setting goal earned Alonso Martínez Player of the Match. Plus, a rundown of the final Leagues Cup ratings for every New York City FC player who saw the field in the tournament.
One of New York City FC's best performances of the season brings with it a set of positive player ratings, with two standouts from the win over Tigres rated in the high 8s.
The vibes are steady after New York City FC get it done on the road – and in the rain – to advance to the Leagues Cup Round of 16.
For New York City FC, the Leagues Cup group stage ended with a brutal loss and a set of brutal player ratings.
