Moments ago, the MLS Disciplinary Committee announced that Toronto FC head coach John Herdman and goalkeeper Sean Johnson will be suspended for today's game against Nashville SC following their actions on the field after their loss to New York City FC on Saturday night at BMO Field.
In addition, Toronto midfielder Richie Laryea will be suspended. Laryea was wearing street clothes and not a part of the matchday squad while out recovering from hamstring surgery, yet was front-and-center in the BMO melee.
The MLS Disciplinary Committee also announced that the one-game suspensions of New York City FC defender Strahinja Tanasijević and Toronto striker Prince Owusu, reported yesterday, will be served today.
• Toronto, head coach John Herdman, suspended for 1 game
• Toronto, Sean Johnson, suspended for 1 game
• Toronto, Richie Laryea, suspended for 1 game
• New York City, Strahinja Tanasijević, red card, suspended for 1 game
• Toronto, Prince Owusu, red card, suspended for 1 game
Tom Bogert of The Athletic first reported the suspensions yesterday. His article reported that the suspensions of Tanasijević and Owusu would be extended to two games, and that Laryea would be suspended for three games. Bogert noted in his article that multi-game suspensions may be appealed.
But longer suspensions are still a possibility. The official statement from the MLS Disciplinary Committee stated it will continue "to assess the incident and those involved for further discipline, and will announce complete findings and sanctions at a later date."
With these rulings from the MLS Disciplinary Committee, Saturday's game led to a total of six suspensions for Toronto—TFC’s Federico Bernardeschi, Kevin Long are also suspended for non-melee reasons—and one suspension for New York City.
Footage from the Apple TV broadcast gives a field-level view of some of the confrontations, including the ones between Johnson and Tanasijević.
Altercation after the final whistle between Toronto FC and NYCFC.
— Tom Bogert (@tombogert) May 12, 2024
Sean Johnson and Strahinja Tanasijević in the middle of it. pic.twitter.com/qsIRc9Oqhb
Here's another angle from Apple TV.
Another angle here of Sean Johnson and Strahinja Tanasijević. https://t.co/BvDIK8ZIeg pic.twitter.com/KyoaPPppWg
— Tom Bogert (@tombogert) May 12, 2024
Here is the full statement from the MLS Disciplinary Committee:
Toronto-New York City incident
While the MLS Disciplinary Committee continues to review the post-match incident between New York City FC and Toronto FC on May 11, the following individuals have been suspended for May 15 games due to their involvement:
Toronto FC head coach John Herdman
Toronto FC defender Richie Laryea
Toronto FC goalkeeper Sean Johnson
Toronto FC forward Prince Owusu and New York City FC defender Strahinja Tanasijevic each received red cards for their involvement in the post-match incident. Owusu will serve his red card suspension against Nashville SC on May 15, and Tanasijevic will serve his red card suspension against the Philadelphia Union on May 15.
The MLS Disciplinary Committee continues to assess the incident and those involved for further discipline, and will announce complete findings and sanctions at a later date.
On Monday, Herdman was asked about his on-field behavior in a pregame press conference. The Toronto head coach replied that he did nothing wrong, and that he confronted New York City FC head coach Nick Cushing because he felt Cushing was involved in the dust-ups taking place.
Here is a close-up from the Apple TV footage of Herdman rushing Cushing.
A closeup of @TorontoFC head coach John Herdman rushing @newyorkcityfc head coach Nick Cushing while players mix it up -
— Hudson River Blue (@hudsonriverblue) May 12, 2024
Cushing not involved when Herdman bumps into him with his chest, Cushing continues to walk away
Clip credit: @rrusselljr93
pic.twitter.com/0CJTRVtm06
In Monday’s press conference, Herdman also repeated the allegation he made Saturday night that Cushing punched a Toronto player in the tunnel at Yankee Stadium when the two teams played each other on March 16.
Cushing held a pregame press conference shortly after, and began by making a statement in which he categorically denied assaulting any player or staff member. Cushing went on to explain that New York City officially requested that MLS investigate the alleged incidents. The club said they turned over all security footage from that day to the league and Toronto FC in March.
This post will be updated as new information becomes available.